Everybody is talking about how "Agile" makes you succeed.
However, Agile is not a silver bullet. As an empirical process, there are many failures on the way to success.
In this blog, I want to share the failures from which I have learned so that others may also learn.
When companies transition to Scrum, or any other Agile methodology, they usually start with the problem of arranging all the identified "undone work". Where do we start?
In the worst case, huge amounts of "overdue" items are all considered "Priority 1". In this situation, the Product Owner must clearly indicate where the team should start.
Other organizations seem to suffer from a kind of collection addiction, keeping a backlog of hundreds of items that won't ever get done.
Here are some tips for maintaining a nice, tidy, workable backlog.
Intially setting up a backlog
Before even bothering to produce detailed user stories or doing task breakdown, the Product Owner should simply draft out the basic areas of the Product.
Post-It notes with maybe one or two words will do the trick. Then, draft the matrix below on a board and place the sticky notes:
The backlog item placement matrix
Put your backlog items on this matrix!
When weeding out based on impact, you must identify your customers and stakeholders. For each item you identified, you must ask "Who will suffer if this is not implemented?"
If the impact of not implementing the item is low or not even measurable, the item is certainly not important.
Next, you weed out based on urgency. A good initial question to ask when chaffing out for initial urgency is: "If we do not deliver within 1 month, will there be significant damage to our business case?" - if the answer is "no", the item has low urgency.
If you're unsure, feel free to put the item on the dividing line between low/high.
When that region clutters, you can benchmark by using the top item on the dividing line. Ask yourself for each item: "Does this have higher impact / urgency?" to make a decision quickly.
Ideally, you will end up with a good number of items in the "Scrap" section. Congratulations, they are off the table! You do not need to waste any further minute with these topics.
For anything in the section "Defer": put those items on the bottom of your backlog and leave them there. Do not waste time now grooming them, because you will not work with them in the near future.
For anything in the section "Why?":
If you would invest a lot of effort for little impact, move the item to the "Scrap" section.
When you're just starting a new product, it's probably a bad idea to have anything from this in your backlog, because you want to get your product going - NOW!
When you're working on an existing product, you may want to look for "quick wins" in this section. Anything that will give you a credibility boost at low cost should be considered.
As long as the item still has a positive Return on Investment, you should do it, but only if you can squeeze it into the schedule.
Only groom items which will bring your product ahead with minimal effort.
Move the others into the backlog until further notice.
Should you have significantly more than five items here or dispute over priority, you need to weed out further.
The items remaining in this section are your high level backlog ("Epic items").
These items need to be made workable, such as by using INVEST. Break them down to feature level and start with the Story Breakdown.
If you feel uncertain about being too lax with weeding and up with a cluttered "Do Now" section", you should use "Magic Numbering" on the cards twice.
During the first round, simply arrange the cards by impact. After finishing, arrange them into buckets from 1 to 5 with ascending impact and note the impact on the cards. Unless you have less than 6 items, each number should have at least 1 item.
During the second round, arrange the cards by urgency from "low" to "high" in ascending order from left to right.
Then, use the noted numbers of impact to move the cards up (high impact) or down (low impact). Make sure their horizontal position remains unchanged. when arranging them on the vertical axis.
Afterwards, draw the lines - not in the middle, but between the "3" and "4" rows and columns, so purposefully create a bias towards "High".
Wrapping it up
You may flinch when you see that "lots of valuable stuff has gone off the list", but if you did the arrangement correctly, only "even more valuable stuff will get done".
Your initial backlog should be very small and tidy at this point, easily workable for further breakdown.
Likewise, you can immediately and effectively quench discussion about any other topic with the simple argument "It won't get done now, anyway".
You can apply the same process with the story / feature breakdown of each item. When moving into the first sprint of the team, it's actually a good idea to not overload the team with information. Weed the Ready ("groomed, broken down, workable") backlog to no more than five workable items for the first sprint.
After the sprint, you will learn about the team's capacity. The amount of items you need to have Ready for the next Sprint should be roughly equal to twice the team's velocity.
Once an Epic ("high level") item is fully groomed and there are not enough Ready items in the backlog, you take the next Epic and break it down. Start with the "Do Now" items and pull from "Defer" or the "Quick Wins", depending on what currently makes more sense.
Impact and Urgency are subject to change. For instance, in May, the annual fiscal report is not urgent - in December, that's an entirely different story! Or, you have a customer threatening with a lawsuit - that may make an otherwise insignificant topic very urgent.
Whenever an item is added to / removed from the Epic Backlog, priorities may change. Between each sprint, you should bother taking a couple of minutes to do an iteration of weeding to make sure you are properly set up for the next sprint.
Consequently, stories that were groomed on a detailed level may move to the "Scrap" section. That is okay. If the current product priorities indicate that this makes sense - so be it!
Don't bother tracking backlog that nobody will work on in the near future.
A good indicator of when you should weed:
You have items in the backlog that were not touched for more than 3 Sprints, and nobody has bothered asking about them.
Use frequent weeding to keep a significant, concise backlog.